When tenants violate lease terms or stop paying rent, Florida landlords must act quickly—but how? Should you file an eviction or take them to small claims court? This guide breaks down the differences, benefits, and correct use of each legal process so you can recover your property—or your money—efficiently and legally.
What Is an Eviction?
An eviction is a legal action to remove a tenant from your rental property due to:
- Non-payment of rent
- Lease violations (like unauthorized occupants or pets)
- Property damage or illegal activity
- Staying after the lease has ended (holdover tenancy)
The eviction process in Florida follows Chapter 83 of the Florida Statutes, which outlines the legal steps landlords must take to remove a tenant. This process ensures that landlords can regain legal possession of the rental unit while staying fully compliant with state law. However, even a small procedural error—like incorrect notice delivery or missing paperwork—can delay the case or lead to dismissal. That’s why working with an experienced eviction lawyer in Florida is crucial. At Pronto Evictions, we help landlords handle the eviction process swiftly, lawfully, and with minimal stress.
Important: Evictions do not automatically recover unpaid rent or damage costs.
What Is Small Claims Court?
Small claims court is used when you’re seeking financial compensation after a tenant has moved out. You can sue for:
- Unpaid rent
- Physical damage to the unit
- Cleaning or repair costs
- Lease-breaking penalties
Florida’s small claims courts handle disputes under $8,000 (excluding court fees and legal expenses). This process is completely separate from eviction.
Key Differences
Here’s how they compare, side by side:
Eviction:
- Purpose: Remove a tenant from the property
- Used when: The tenant still occupies the unit
- Outcome: Regain possession of your rental
- Does not recover: Money, unpaid rent, or damages
Small Claims:
- Purpose: Recover money owed to you
- Used when: The tenant has vacated (voluntarily or via eviction)
- Outcome: Court judgment for financial compensation
- Does not: Remove a tenant from the property
When to Choose Eviction
Choose eviction when:
- The tenant is still occupying the property
- Rent is unpaid and notices have been ignored
- There are lease violations that warrant removal
- You need to re-rent the unit legally and quickly
For legal eviction support, read: The Hidden Crisis: How Landlords Are Being Pushed to the Brink
When to Choose Small Claims
Choose small claims court when:
- The tenant has already moved out or been evicted
- You’re seeking unpaid rent, cleaning, or repair costs
- The total amount is under $8,000
Even if you have already evicted the tenant, you can still file small claims afterward to recover financial losses.
Can You File Both?
Yes. Here’s the sequence:
- Evict first (if tenant is still present)
- File small claims after you regain possession
Each serves a unique purpose:
- Eviction = Remove tenant
- Small Claims = Recover money
Real-Life Example
Scenario: A tenant owes 2 months of rent and has left your unit with $3,000 in damages.
1. File for eviction to remove them (if they’re still in the unit).
2. Once they’re gone, file in small claims court to recover:
- $3,000 in damages
- 2 months of unpaid rent
Need help tracking communication before things escalate?
Legal Tips Before Filing
- Document everything: lease, payments, texts, photos, damages
- Serve proper notices under Florida law
- Keep copies of invoices or repair bills
- Don’t attempt illegal "self-help" actions like changing locks
Why Hire an Eviction Attorney?
Even minor mistakes can delay your eviction or cost you money. A legal expert ensures:
- Proper service of notices
- Correct court filings
- Speedy resolution and fewer delays
At Pronto Evictions, we’ve helped thousands of Florida landlords protect their rights and recover losses—fast, legally, and affordably.
Final Thoughts
If you need your tenant out—eviction is the path.
If you need your money back—small claims is the way.
Sometimes, you’ll need both. Either way, knowing the difference puts you in control.
Need Help with Eviction or Claims?
Let the experienced team at Pronto Evictions handle it for you.
Visit: https://prontoevictions.com
Visit: https://prontoevictions.com
Location: Florida
Phone no. 954-539-7770 or 813- 250-2900
Protect your rental property—the right way.
Leave A Comment